Skip to content
The Care Home Check

Nutley Lodge Care Home

Nutley Lodge, 43 Sherford Road, Plymouth, PL9 8DA

Residential, dementia · 27 registered beds Nutley Lodge Care Home

CQC overall rating

Requires improvement
Assessed 6 January 2025 · 1 year ago

01 / At a glance

The things that matter first.

A 27-bed residential care home in Plymouth, run by Nutley Lodge Care Home since December 2010. It’s registered to care for adults over 65, including people with dementia and physical disabilities.

Latest CQC rating Requires improvementAssessed 6 January 2025 · 1 year agoAlso Requires improvement at the assessment before (January 2024)
Registered manager In post since at least October 20231 registered manager since October 2023.
Food hygiene Very goodKitchen inspected 29 May 2026
The owner This home onlyNo other care homes on CQC’s register

What to know

Our reading of the public records · How we decide
  • January 2025
    CQC found breaches of regulations
    Safe care and treatment, good governance, staffing, consent and recruitment. CQC’s words are quoted below.
Manager and owner
  • Registered manager in post since at least October 2023
    1 registered manager since October 2023.
  • Run by Nutley Lodge Care Home since December 2010

The five key questions

  • Requires improvement Safe, Effective and Well-led
  • Good Caring and Responsive
4 similar residential homes nearby

Care provided

  • Residential care
  • Adults over 65
  • Dementia
  • Physical disabilities
  • 27 registered beds

02 / The inspection

What CQC found.

Assessed 6 January 2025 · assessment published 16 April 2025

“The service is not performing as well as it should and we have told the service how it must improve.”
CQC’s summary of the January 2025 assessment

The five key questions, with CQC’s scores

  • Safe Requires improvement · 53%
    “This service is not always safe”
  • Effective Requires improvement · 58%
    “This service is not always effective”
  • Caring Good · 75%
    “This service is caring”
  • Responsive Good · 75%
    “This service is responsive”
  • Well-led Requires improvement · 54%
    “This service is not always well-led”

The coloured band is the rating CQC gave; the dot shows roughly where CQC’s score sits on its scale. CQC sets the rating, so a score near the edge of a band can still be rated either side of it.

Breaches of regulations found in January 2025

“The provider was in breach of legal regulations in relation to safe care and treatment and consent.”
“The provider was in breach of legal regulations in relation to safe environments, safe care and treatment, staffing, and fit and proper persons (recruitment).”
“There are continued breaches of 4 regulations in relation to safe care and treatment, consent, good governance and staffing.”
“We also identified 2 additional breaches in relation to fit and proper persons (recruitment) and safe environments.”

CQC’s own words. A breach may have been put right since; CQC checks at its next assessment.

What people told CQC1 paragraph, in CQC’s words

We spoke with 4 people living at the service and gained feedback from 7 relatives to help us assess and understand how people’s care needs were being met. People and their relatives were positive about the quality of care. People told us they enjoyed the food at the service. Relatives told us, “Outstanding is undoubtedly my overall impression of Nutley Lodge in every way.” Another told us, “The care provided is just wonderful.” They told us they could visit at any time and appreciated the different communication methods used to keep them up to date. We used observation to assess whether people received good care. We observed staff being kind and offering choices to people.

CQC’s full summaryWhat CQC found across the service

Nutley Lodge Care Home is a care home that provides accommodation for persons who require personal care for up to 27 people living at the service. The service specialises in providing care to adults over 65 years with dementia and/or physical disabilities.

At our last assessment, we rated the service requires improvement. The service remains requires improvement, however we did find some areas of improvement. There are continued breaches of 4 regulations in relation to safe care and treatment, consent, good governance and staffing. We also identified 2 additional breaches in relation to fit and proper persons (recruitment) and safe environments. The registered manager did not always ensure they were working in accordance with the requirements of the Mental Capacity Act 2005. The service did not always ensure risks were mitigated as reasonably practicable. The service did not always ensure the premises were properly maintained and clean. The service did not always ensure staff received regular appraisals. Systems and processes had not highlighted all the shortfalls identified from this assessment. We asked the provider for an action plan in response to the concerns found at this assessment. People were treated with kindness, empathy and compassion and staff respected people’s privacy and dignity.

Quality statement scoresCQC’s scores, 1 to 4, behind the five ratings
Safe
  • Learning culture3 · Good standard
  • Safe systems, pathways and transitions3 · Good standard
  • Safeguarding3 · Good standard
  • Involving people to manage risks1 · Significant shortfalls
  • Safe environments1 · Significant shortfalls
  • Safe and effective staffing2 · Some shortfalls
  • Infection prevention and control2 · Some shortfalls
  • Medicines optimisation2 · Some shortfalls
Effective
  • Assessing needs3 · Good standard
  • Delivering evidence-based care and treatment2 · Some shortfalls
  • How staff, teams and services work together3 · Good standard
  • Supporting people to live healthier lives3 · Good standard
  • Monitoring and improving outcomes1 · Significant shortfalls
  • Consent to care and treatment2 · Some shortfalls
Caring
  • Independence, choice and control3 · Good standard
Responsive
  • Equity in experiences and outcomes3 · Good standard
Well-led
  • Shared direction and culture3 · Good standard
  • Capable, compassionate and inclusive leaders2 · Some shortfalls
  • Freedom to speak up2 · Some shortfalls
  • Workforce equality, diversity and inclusion3 · Good standard
  • Governance, management and sustainability1 · Significant shortfalls
  • Partnerships and communities3 · Good standard
  • Learning, improvement and innovation1 · Significant shortfalls

The home’s history

  1. January 2025
    Requires improvement Assessed 6 January 2025 under CQC’s new framework, published 16 April 2025. Safe, Effective and Well-led rated Requires improvement.
  2. January 2024
    Requires improvement Assessed 9 January 2024 under CQC’s new framework, published 2 October 2024. Safe, Effective and Well-led rated Requires improvement.
  3. December 2017
    Good Inspected 18 December 2017, report published 17 March 2018
  4. August 2015
    Good Inspected 18 August 2015, report published 11 September 2015. Well-led rated Requires improvement.

Other inspections

5Food hygiene: Very good
Kitchen inspected 29 May 2026 · Food Standards Agency (opens in a new tab), rated 0 to 5

03 / Behind the home

Who runs Nutley Lodge Care Home?

Nutley Lodge Care Home
Registered provider since December 2010

Run by Nutley Lodge Care Home since December 2010.

Company status
Partnership
No Companies House number on CQC’s record.
Registered manager
In post since at least October 2023
1 registered manager since October 2023.
Owner history
The same owner since 2010
No change of owner on CQC’s records.

04 / Planning a visit

Fees, funding and getting there.

Fees: we don’t have Nutley Lodge Care Home’s fees. Ask the home for a written fee schedule, including what’s extra.

Local costs, for comparison

These are not Nutley Lodge Care Home’s prices.

What the council pays
£873 a week
Plymouth paid care homes this on average for a residential place for someone 65 or over (2024–25). If you pay for yourself, homes usually charge more.
Will the council help pay?

In England from April 2026: with over £23,250 in savings and assets you usually pay in full; under £14,250 the council funds your care, with a contribution from your income.

Help with paying for care

Address

Nutley Lodge, 43 Sherford Road, Plymouth, PL9 8DA

Getting there

  • Nearest railway stationPlymouth, 3.9 miles
  • Bus stops within 5 minutes’ walk13, nearest 1 minute away

Health care nearby

The nearest surgery isn’t always the one residents use. Ask the home which GP practice looks after them.

Everything on this page comes from public records, such as CQC, Companies House and the Food Standards Agency. We don’t endorse any home. If something’s wrong, the organisation that holds the record can correct it, and we’ll pick up the change. How we check

Spotted something wrong?Let us know what’s incorrect and we’ll look into it. If the information comes from a public record, we’ll point you towards the organisation responsible for updating it.If you have concerns about the care someone is receiving, contact your local council or CQC. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999. Tell us

This isn't for concerns about someone's care. If someone is in danger, call 999. Otherwise contact the council's adult social care team, or tell CQC through Give feedback on care (opens in a new tab).

Please don't include names or health details of residents or staff.

Help families get a better picture

Do you run Nutley Lodge Care Home? Share details that CQC’s records don’t cover, such as your fees, rooms, visiting arrangements and activities.

Claim this page