Skip to content
The Care Home Check

George Edward Smart Homes

Combe Hay House, Stepney Drive, Scarborough, YO12 5DJ

Residential · 60 registered beds The George Edward Smart Homes

CQC overall rating

Requires improvement
Inspected 8 March 2023 · 3 years ago

01 / At a glance

The things that matter first.

A 60-bed residential care home in Scarborough, run by The George Edward Smart Homes, a charity, since January 2011. It’s registered to care for adults over 65.

Latest CQC rating Requires improvementInspected 8 March 2023 · 3 years agoDown from Good (November 2018)CQC hasn’t rated it again since. Ask the home what has changed.
Registered manager In post since about September 20263 registered managers since October 2023. No registered manager for 4 months (May 2025 to August 2025).
Food hygiene No rating foundNot matched on the Food Standards Agency’s register
The owner This home onlyNo other care homes on CQC’s register

What to know

Our reading of the public records · How we decide
  • March 2023
    CQC found breaches of regulations
    Safe care and treatment and good governance. CQC’s words are quoted below.
  • March 2023
    Requires improvement for 3 years
    CQC hasn’t rated the home again since. Any later visits are in the rating history.
Manager and owner
  • Registered manager in post since about September 2026
    3 registered managers since October 2023. No registered manager for 4 months (May 2025 to August 2025).
  • Run by The George Edward Smart Homes since January 2011
    Registered charity: income £0, spending £0 (year to 31 December 2025).

The five key questions

  • Requires improvement Safe and Well-led
  • Good Effective, Caring and Responsive
4 similar residential homes nearby

Care provided

  • Residential care
  • Adults over 65
  • 60 registered beds

02 / The inspection

What CQC found.

Inspected 8 March 2023 · report published 12 April 2023

“A range of audits and quality checks were completed. However, there was no clear strategy in place at provider level and no operational plan to ensure systems and process remained established to maintain accurate and complete records of people's care.”
From CQC’s summary of the March 2023 inspection, in CQC’s words.Read the rest of CQC’s summary ↓

Breaches of regulations found in March 2023

“Enforcement We have identified breaches in relation to the management of the service and provider oversight (including risk management and governance checks).”
“This was a breach of regulation 12(1) (Safe care and treatment) of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014.”
“A failure to maintain securely an accurate, complete and contemporaneous record in respect of each person was a breach of Regulation 17(2) (Good Governance) of the Health and Social Care Act 2008 (Regulated Activities) Regulations 2014.”

CQC’s own words. A breach may have been put right since; CQC checks at its next inspection.

CQC’s full summaryWhat CQC found, 9 paragraphs in CQC’s words

A range of audits and quality checks were completed. However, there was no clear strategy in place at provider level and no operational plan to ensure systems and process remained established to maintain accurate and complete records of people's care.

Risk assessments and associated support plans used by staff as a point of reference were not always up to date or completed which put people at risk of otherwise avoidable harm. There was limited use of systems to take a holistic view of people's needs, to record, manage and report concerns about risks, safety and incidents.

People told us they received their medicines safely. However, medicine audits failed to look holistically at medicines management and administration resulting in areas of incomplete record keeping.

People received support from a range of health professionals when required. However, care plans including risk assessments and support plans were not routinely updated to reflect any required changes for staff to use.

We looked at infection prevention and control measures under the Safe key question.

The home was well maintained, clean with access to large outside garden and seating areas. Staff had good access to personal protective equipment to manage the risks associated with the spread of infection including Coronavirus and adhered to government guidance to protect people.

People were supported to have maximum choice and control of their lives and staff supported them in the least restrictive way possible and in their best interests; the policies and systems in the service supported this practice.

People told us they felt safe and were happy with their care. Enough suitably trained staff were employed who were knowledgeable and skilled. Staff received appropriate training and support to carry out their roles.

The manager was aware of the improvements required. Observations and feedback confirmed the failings we found had a low impact on people at the time of the inspection, but people were at risk if the required improvements were not quickly implemented.

Why CQC inspectedIn CQC’s words

We received concerns in relation to the management of the home, provider oversight, management of risks and staffing. As a result, we undertook a focused inspection to review the key questions of safe and well led only. For those key questions not inspected, we used the ratings awarded at the last inspection to calculate the overall rating. The overall rating for the service has changed from good to requires improvement based on the findings of this inspection.

We have found evidence the provider needs to make improvements. Please see the safe and well led sections of this full report.

You can see what action we have asked the provider to take at the end of this full report.

About the serviceAs CQC described it in March 2023

George Edward Smart Homes is a residential care home providing regulated activity of personal care to up to 60 older people. At the time of our inspection there were 44 people using the service.

Read the full report on CQC’s website (opens in a new tab)

The home’s history

  1. March 2023
    Requires improvement Inspected 8 March 2023, report published 12 April 2023. Safe and Well-led rated Requires improvement.
  2. March 2021
    Inspected, not rated Inspected 23 March 2021, report published 22 April 2021
  3. November 2018
    Good Inspected 5 November 2018, report published 3 January 2019
  4. August 2017
    Requires improvement Inspected 31 August 2017, report published 5 December 2017. Safe and Well-led rated Requires improvement.
  5. March 2015
    Good Inspected 24 March 2015, report published 11 September 2015. Effective rated Requires improvement.

“Inspected, not rated” visits don’t change the rating.

03 / Behind the home

Who runs George Edward Smart Homes?

The George Edward Smart Homes
Registered provider since January 2011 · a registered charity

Run by The George Edward Smart Homes, a registered charity, since January 2011.

Charity
Registered
Income £0, spending £0 (year to 31 December 2025). Charity 207164 on the register (opens in a new tab)
Registered manager
In post since about September 2026
3 registered managers since October 2023. No registered manager for 4 months (May 2025 to August 2025).
Owner history
The same owner since 2011
No change of owner on CQC’s records.

04 / Planning a visit

Fees, funding and getting there.

Fees: we don’t have George Edward Smart Homes’s fees. Ask the home for a written fee schedule, including what’s extra.

Local costs, for comparison

These are not George Edward Smart Homes’s prices.

What the council pays
£1,274 a week
North Yorkshire paid care homes this on average for a residential place for someone 65 or over (2024–25). If you pay for yourself, homes usually charge more.
Will the council help pay?

In England from April 2026: with over £23,250 in savings and assets you usually pay in full; under £14,250 the council funds your care, with a contribution from your income.

Help with paying for care

Address

Combe Hay House, Stepney Drive, Scarborough, YO12 5DJ

Getting there

  • Nearest railway stationScarborough, 1.0 miles
  • Bus stops within 5 minutes’ walk9, nearest 3 minutes away

Health care nearby

The nearest surgery isn’t always the one residents use. Ask the home which GP practice looks after them.

Everything on this page comes from public records, such as CQC, Companies House and the Food Standards Agency. We don’t endorse any home. If something’s wrong, the organisation that holds the record can correct it, and we’ll pick up the change. How we check

Spotted something wrong?Let us know what’s incorrect and we’ll look into it. If the information comes from a public record, we’ll point you towards the organisation responsible for updating it.If you have concerns about the care someone is receiving, contact your local council or CQC. If someone is in immediate danger, call 999. Tell us

This isn't for concerns about someone's care. If someone is in danger, call 999. Otherwise contact the council's adult social care team, or tell CQC through Give feedback on care (opens in a new tab).

Please don't include names or health details of residents or staff.

Help families get a better picture

Do you run George Edward Smart Homes? Share details that CQC’s records don’t cover, such as your fees, rooms, visiting arrangements and activities.

Claim this page